Let’s talk about Noelle.
Because I’m not over it.
She was strong, self-made, and carrying a decade’s worth of heartbreak like armor.
The kind of girl who rebuilt her life from nothing and swore she’d never let the same people hurt her twice.
And the moment she started softening before they truly earned it???
That’s when I knew.
Not satisfying.
Not convincing.
But rushed.
I wanted to understand her, but they didn’t give her the time she deserved.
And honestly? She forgave them way too easily.
But here’s the problem:
The grovel wasn’t groveling.
Shepard, Robin, and Frost broke her heart in a way that should’ve taken time, effort, and emotional wreckage to repair.
We’re talking:
- deep regret
- consistent proving
- real consequences
Instead, it felt like we got apologies wrapped in pretty words and just enough tension to almost deliver.
And she?
She deserved better.
What Didn’t Hit:
- Forgiveness Felt Rushed: Ten years of pain smoothed over far too quickly.
- Lack of Emotional Consequences: The Alphas didn’t show nearly enough growth.
- Missed Angst Potential: This could’ve been gut-wrenching, but it pulled its punches.
What Still Worked:
- The holiday setting adds cozy contrast to the angst
- The heroine’s initial strength? Absolutely compelling
ROMANCEAHOLIC’S MISSED-THE-MARK STAMP
Grovel could have been an all-time favorite if the emotional payoff matched the setup. Because in romances like this, we’re not just here for love. We’re here for redemption that hurts.
A compelling setup with plenty of angst and longing, but if you’re here for hardcore grovel and slow-earned forgiveness, this one might leave you wanting more.

Every book finds its reader… this one just didn’t hit me the way I needed it to.
🖤 Romanceaholic
Romanceaholic exists for readers who know love stories should hit harder, but don’t always. Because not every hyped book delivers, not every trope lives up to its promise, and not every romance earns its happily ever after.
This is where we question the chemistry, call out the missing depth, and admit when a story just… didn’t feel enough.
If you’re ready for romance that holds, begin here:
Carmen’s Keepers | The Keeper Shelf | Stayed Up, No Regrets
Because hype fades.
Devotion endures.
Follow Romanceaholic for curated recommendations, cultural commentary, and love stories that linger long after the final page.
Instagram • Facebook • Threads • Pinterest
🖤 The Romanceaholic Shop
Notebooks and reading companions for annotators, trope lovers, and readers who take their devotion seriously.
Because every unforgettable love story deserves margin notes.
🖤 Romanceaholic
A Digital Romance Magazine
Love stories. Taken seriously.
